Prestige Barbershop Professional v4.37.0
Deep Audit Final Report

Scope:
1. Payment-before-approval for Member and Pra-Member.
2. Mandatory member photo.
3. Manual/selfie attendance photo + GPS + server timestamp.

Functional rules verified:
- Member registration cannot be submitted without photo (HTML required + server validation).
- Data Member cannot create a member without photo; editing legacy member without photo requires upload first.
- Pra-Member payment flow requires member photo before payment is recorded.
- Approval Member/Pra-Member has no Approve button until linked membership payment is PAID.
- Server-side approval guard also rejects direct/forged approval requests before payment.
- QRIS/Transfer/E-Wallet pre-approval payments require proof and verification.
- Cash pre-approval payment can settle immediately after sufficient cash amount.
- Payment finalization for pending applications does not activate member; activation occurs only at Approval.
- Manual attendance requires photo + GPS.
- Staff self attendance requires selfie + GPS.
- Attendance time uses Asia/Jakarta server time; UI shows Indonesian day/date/time and GPS coordinates/accuracy/map link.

Audit results:
- PHP files checked: 177
- PHP syntax errors: 0
- Fresh database tables: 77
- Foreign-key references checked: 143
- Foreign-key missing/order issues: 0
- Missing local include/require targets: 0
- Missing local PHP href/action targets: 0
- POST forms checked: 192
- CSRF heuristic: only setup.php excluded as bootstrap installer
- Files from stable v4.35.1 preserved: 280 / 280
- CREATE DATABASE in database.sql: NO
- USE database in database.sql: NO
- Upgrade v4.37.0 PHP: present
- Upgrade v4.37.0 SQL fallback: present
- schema_release target: 4.37.0

Production deployment:
- Backup database and application.
- Preserve config/database.local.php and uploads.
- Apply patch over v4.35.1, preserving directory structure.
- Login Super Admin and run upgrade_v4_37_0.php.
- Do not import database.sql into an existing production database.
- Use upgrade_v4_37_0.sql only if PHP upgrade cannot alter the schema.
